What’s So Wrong With Hierarchy?
12 responses to “What’s So Wrong With Hierarchy?”
-
Do you feel that electronic collaboration, behaviour by the big boss could stop this kind of nonsense ?
-
Do you feel that electronic collaboration, behaviour by the big boss could stop this kind of nonsense ?
-
While your analysis is telling, what’s the alternative? I have a client who has just re-organised into a series of ‘communities’ with zero hierarchy. Where everyone in the department of around 100 people report into the boss. Where people choose how much of their time to devote to each community, where everyone democratically decides what to work on, where ‘facilitators’ (never leaders) vary from task to task. The result? Far worse paralysis than you describe. if the price of getting stuff done is duplication and make-work then increasingly I’m all for it. Unless there’s a middle ground of course…
-
While your analysis is telling, what’s the alternative? I have a client who has just re-organised into a series of ‘communities’ with zero hierarchy. Where everyone in the department of around 100 people report into the boss. Where people choose how much of their time to devote to each community, where everyone democratically decides what to work on, where ‘facilitators’ (never leaders) vary from task to task. The result? Far worse paralysis than you describe. if the price of getting stuff done is duplication and make-work then increasingly I’m all for it. Unless there’s a middle ground of course…
-
Neil. While I agree with the need to stop ineffective runarounds And people dishing work off onto others, what is your alternative in this scenario you have presented.
We mustn’t forget the benefit of hiearchy: accountability.
Without hierarchy, no one person is empowered to make the final call. Committees are great and all, but for getting things done, they can be murder.
I’m all for hierarchy in small teams that can move fast and get things done. -
Neil. While I agree with the need to stop ineffective runarounds And people dishing work off onto others, what is your alternative in this scenario you have presented.
We mustn’t forget the benefit of hiearchy: accountability.
Without hierarchy, no one person is empowered to make the final call. Committees are great and all, but for getting things done, they can be murder.
I’m all for hierarchy in small teams that can move fast and get things done. -
This scenario is not a failure of hierarchy – its a failure of leadership. Acts of leadership need to be present throughout the org – pick the right fight.
-
This scenario is not a failure of hierarchy – its a failure of leadership. Acts of leadership need to be present throughout the org – pick the right fight.
-
Hi Kevin – good to hear from you. I take your point, but I feel that systems have a way of creating their own processes which often act to protect the existing structures, relationship capital, ways of doing things. So if hierarchy is overburdensome, so are the processes associated with it.
-
Hi Kevin – good to hear from you. I take your point, but I feel that systems have a way of creating their own processes which often act to protect the existing structures, relationship capital, ways of doing things. So if hierarchy is overburdensome, so are the processes associated with it.
-
@garrett thanks for the comment. I’ve written quite a lot over time around ways of working which I believe are more suited to the environment in which we all operate. The Agile Planning tab on the top Nav Bar has a collection of posts around this and related subjects if that helps 🙂
-
@garrett thanks for the comment. I’ve written quite a lot over time around ways of working which I believe are more suited to the environment in which we all operate. The Agile Planning tab on the top Nav Bar has a collection of posts around this and related subjects if that helps 🙂
Leave a Reply