Posted on 

 by 

 in 

The Cynical Organisation

Reading about some of the tumultuous change going on right now in some of world's biggest tech businesses, one can't help but feel for the workers caught at the sharp end, trying to make sense of the latest senior management missive or strategy. Missives that often talk about the need for accelerated innovation and a culture of experimentation.

And yet, what's the biggest killer of experimentation? Cynicism. What causes cynicism? Lack of belief, frustration, blame, fear. It so easily happens.

In Change By Design, Tim Brown of IDEO talks about how curiousity does not survive in organisations that have grown cynical. How ideas get smothered, risk-takers driven-out, projects with uncertain outcomes avoided: "even when leadership wants to promote disruptive innovation and open-ended experimentation, it will find that no-one is willing to step forward without permission – which usually means defeat before the start." 

He's so right. Compare that those organisations that seem to be so accomplished at creating and maintaining positive momentum, who adeptly manage the challenge of competing internal priorities, who are able to marshall people around a powerful vision and inclusive working practices.

As Tim Brown says, when we talk about creating a culture of experimentation, perhaps we don't talk enough about creating it's essential counterpart – a climate of optimism.

4 responses to “The Cynical Organisation”

  1. Paul Suggett Avatar
    Paul Suggett

    Bravo. I absolutely believe this. You cannot change the work without changing the environment in which it’s produced. It’s like trying to grow a new bumper crop of vegetables in a field that’s had all the nutrients sucked out, and replaced with landfill and old microwaves.
    Thanks for the insight.

  2. Paul Suggett Avatar
    Paul Suggett

    Bravo. I absolutely believe this. You cannot change the work without changing the environment in which it’s produced. It’s like trying to grow a new bumper crop of vegetables in a field that’s had all the nutrients sucked out, and replaced with landfill and old microwaves.
    Thanks for the insight.

  3. Holycow Avatar
    Holycow

    Great provocation Neil thanks.
    The only question that arises for me is why organizations become cynical – if cynicism is such a destroyer of creativity?
    Lack of belief, frustration, blame, fear?
    What is the root cause of these negative characteristics I wonder? I suggest it is because a company has failed to deliver and the leaders of that business have failed to manage expectations.
    Being curious is a wonderful thing. But when you are being paid to deliver your promise as a business all the curiosity in the world is useless if doesn’t get delivered.
    “Sorry your plane tickets didn’t arrive on time for your honeymoon – but we are curious about what you did as an alternative”…
    Banks would withdraw from lending money to Pixar if it had 2 consecutive flops.
    Tim Brown is right but only in the context of a company that is currently winning. When things get tough – people do less experimental stuff because it probably isn’t going to help to get them paid at the end of the month.
    Optimism is a wonderful tonic of course – but only works for a limited time. In this economic climate – we have very ‘limited time’.
    Great to see you last night btw – wonderfully insightful and thought provoking – splendid.
    best
    M

  4. Holycow Avatar
    Holycow

    Great provocation Neil thanks.
    The only question that arises for me is why organizations become cynical – if cynicism is such a destroyer of creativity?
    Lack of belief, frustration, blame, fear?
    What is the root cause of these negative characteristics I wonder? I suggest it is because a company has failed to deliver and the leaders of that business have failed to manage expectations.
    Being curious is a wonderful thing. But when you are being paid to deliver your promise as a business all the curiosity in the world is useless if doesn’t get delivered.
    “Sorry your plane tickets didn’t arrive on time for your honeymoon – but we are curious about what you did as an alternative”…
    Banks would withdraw from lending money to Pixar if it had 2 consecutive flops.
    Tim Brown is right but only in the context of a company that is currently winning. When things get tough – people do less experimental stuff because it probably isn’t going to help to get them paid at the end of the month.
    Optimism is a wonderful tonic of course – but only works for a limited time. In this economic climate – we have very ‘limited time’.
    Great to see you last night btw – wonderfully insightful and thought provoking – splendid.
    best
    M

Leave a Reply