Posted on 

 by 

 in , ,

The Problem With Retargeting

Target
…is that it's not quite good enough. We've all had it. Go to a retailer's site, have a bit of a browse not really intending to buy anything, and then you're followed around the web for the next month by said retailer with (usually) not very enticing banner ads that sometimes contain the products you looked at all those weeks ago on the retailer's site. More recently, my own personal corporate stalkers have been a trainer company and an online retailer.

Such retargeting networks are dependent on tracking technology to identify users that have been defined by their browsing behaviour from large 'cookie pools'. In my case though, what the technology doesn't know is that the only reason I went to the retailers site was in the course of doing some research for a project I was working on. What the technology also doesn't know is that after visiting the trainer company's website, I subsequently bought a pair of trainers elsewhere and am now a satisfied customer who doesn't need another pair of trainers right now.

That's the thing about shiny new technology – we get all excited about the possibilities and then the early execution has a lot of holes in it. That's kind of OK, as long as the technology developes rapidly. The problem in this case with being not quite good enough is that it's been not quite good enough for quite some time and can actually prove quite annoying. I was once followed round the web by another online retailer for six months after I visited their site. I realise that it's dependent on the limitations of the data but I can't help but feel that if more care were taken around the execution (more use of frequency capping, more sophisticated application of the data to close the loop better with subsequent user behavoiur to redefine the context, for example) it would be better for everybody. It's about time we made it a bit better I think.

Photo Credit: SantaRosa OLD SKOOL via Compfight cc

8 responses to “The Problem With Retargeting”

  1. John Avatar
    John

    I rarely notice online advertising – that’s the real problem. The whole display advwertising side of the net is a house of cards.

  2. John Avatar
    John

    I rarely notice online advertising – that’s the real problem. The whole display advwertising side of the net is a house of cards.

  3. johntilbury (@johntilbury) Avatar
    johntilbury (@johntilbury)

    Problem isn’t with the technology, but rather the way in which is has been sent up which sounds like sloppy work. A properly set up campaign would stop serving those ads after a period of time through frequency capping. There is a sharp drop off of conversions typically after you have retargeted or a period of time has elapsed since the actual site visit, so to continue posting ads is just wasting money.
    Both the media agency and the adserver would benefit only a small amount from this additional retargeted traffic if they are buying the media through a DSP or charging on a CPM. But the effect on the consumer is huge as it is bloody annoying.
    There are technologies such as Dotomi, which is capable of matching retail activity with online activity, so there is already the start of an evolution in technologies which woud change the retargeted response based on an online or offline purchase you have made. Slowly but surely..

  4. johntilbury (@johntilbury) Avatar
    johntilbury (@johntilbury)

    Problem isn’t with the technology, but rather the way in which is has been sent up which sounds like sloppy work. A properly set up campaign would stop serving those ads after a period of time through frequency capping. There is a sharp drop off of conversions typically after you have retargeted or a period of time has elapsed since the actual site visit, so to continue posting ads is just wasting money.
    Both the media agency and the adserver would benefit only a small amount from this additional retargeted traffic if they are buying the media through a DSP or charging on a CPM. But the effect on the consumer is huge as it is bloody annoying.
    There are technologies such as Dotomi, which is capable of matching retail activity with online activity, so there is already the start of an evolution in technologies which woud change the retargeted response based on an online or offline purchase you have made. Slowly but surely..

  5. Marilyse @marilysedionne Avatar
    Marilyse @marilysedionne

    I wonder if common users notice these targeted ads as much as people in the industry who are aware of the mechanics behind them do. Nevertheless they are annoying; I am still served numerous VW ads a year after I’ve purchased my car, and will see the same advert over and over on YouTube even though i’ve skipped it many times. I wonder why user actions such as skip aren’t captured as profiling data. This would make the ads more relevant and ultimately increase pertinence and engagement …

  6. Marilyse @marilysedionne Avatar
    Marilyse @marilysedionne

    I wonder if common users notice these targeted ads as much as people in the industry who are aware of the mechanics behind them do. Nevertheless they are annoying; I am still served numerous VW ads a year after I’ve purchased my car, and will see the same advert over and over on YouTube even though i’ve skipped it many times. I wonder why user actions such as skip aren’t captured as profiling data. This would make the ads more relevant and ultimately increase pertinence and engagement …

  7. Martin Weigel Avatar
    Martin Weigel

    See Dan Wieden (at 4:42) on the horrors of re-targeting:


  8. Martin Weigel Avatar
    Martin Weigel

    See Dan Wieden (at 4:42) on the horrors of re-targeting:


Leave a Reply