Posted on 

 by 

 in , ,

Designing With Constraints

"You know this moment: time is running out, the team is down by one, a player arcs the ball from downtown just as the buzzer sounds—and sinks it.  it’s exhilarating. It’s heart breaking. And most of all, it’s good design."

Much has been written about how an astute use of constraints can help focus problems and promote creativity. Studies have shown that obstacles of form allow people to think in more all-encompassing ways and that the result of giving free reign to solve a problem is often that people will revert to what worked in the past rather than create an original and different solution. Some of the most creative strategies and executions in media and advertising have come from situations where budget was severely limited. Many believe boundaries like 140 characters or 6 seconds of video or an Instgram-sized square to be important contributory factors to adoption and usage.

So this short 99% Invisible episode on the development of basketball is fascinating in telling the story of how the imposition of constraints were so critical to the huge growth in popularity of the game. It's interesting in itself that for decade after the invention of basketball, the basket was closed at the bottom, requiring the manual retrieval of the ball every time someone scored. But the real turning point for the game came with the imposition of the 24 second stop clock and the heightened tension, emotion and anxiety that that restriction created. It was, in short, a brilliant piece of design.

2 responses to “Designing With Constraints”

  1. Olivier Avatar
    Olivier

    Once of the most interesting piece about benefit of constrains I read recently was from the Pew Research’s study: Teens, Social Media, and Privacy 2013
    and how the 140 character limit in Twitter was avoiding one of the main blame teenagers had about Facebook “block post of drama”
    “Additionally, focus group participants saw the 140-character limit as preventing the type of excesses found on Facebook.
    Male (age 18): “Facebook doesn’t have a limit to characters on it. So in Twitter, there’s only so much you can say. On Facebook, they say so many details of things that you don’t want to know. You’d be like, are you serious? No one really cares that much.”
    http://pewinternet.org/Reports/2013/Teens-Social-Media-And-Privacy/Main-Report/Part-1.aspx
    Very interesting study by the way (and no, Facebook is not dead)

  2. Olivier Avatar
    Olivier

    Once of the most interesting piece about benefit of constrains I read recently was from the Pew Research’s study: Teens, Social Media, and Privacy 2013
    and how the 140 character limit in Twitter was avoiding one of the main blame teenagers had about Facebook “block post of drama”
    “Additionally, focus group participants saw the 140-character limit as preventing the type of excesses found on Facebook.
    Male (age 18): “Facebook doesn’t have a limit to characters on it. So in Twitter, there’s only so much you can say. On Facebook, they say so many details of things that you don’t want to know. You’d be like, are you serious? No one really cares that much.”
    http://pewinternet.org/Reports/2013/Teens-Social-Media-And-Privacy/Main-Report/Part-1.aspx
    Very interesting study by the way (and no, Facebook is not dead)

Leave a Reply